Our Mission Assistance Case Studies Press Room IPAO Forum
HOME : MIB Article : MIB Article : MIB Article
Commentary on the background and importance of the U.S. patent system and proposed reforms.
Commentary on the impacts of specific provisions of the proposed reform legislation.
Discussion of alternatives to patent reform legislation and USPTO operational issues.


Post-Grant Review - Our Next Nightmare? VC Perspective

By John Neis

Managing Director, Venture Investors LLC

Calls for patent reform have been part of the national dialogue for several years now; yet astoundingly there is no meaningful data on the potential economic impact of proposed legislative reforms. Since the start of the recession, the U.S. Government has pumped almost a trillion dollars into stimulus and recovery packages of one form or another. If job creation is Congress's top priority, shouldn't U.S. lawmakers pause to assess the economic consequences of legislation that will profoundly affect America's most reliable stimulant of job growth, namely investments in innovation?

The innovation economy of the United States is the envy of the world. Our venture capital industry accounts for more than 85% of the world's venture capital. In 2008, venture capital-backed companies employed more than 12 million people and generated nearly $3 trillion in revenue. Respectively, these figures accounted for 11% of private sector employment and represented the equivalent of 21% of U.S. GDP during that same year.

Venture-backed companies outperformed the overall economy in terms of creating jobs and growing revenue and venture capital continues to grow entire new industries nearly from scratch. In recent decades, venture capital has played an instrumental role in creating high-tech, high-growth industries such as information technology, biotechnology, semiconductors, online retailing, and most recently, clean technology.

From my vantage point, nothing in the House and Senate patent legislation will stimulate investments in innovative startups and several of the proposed changes, including a much-expanded post-grant review system, will make these investments far riskier and potentially untenable for venture capitalists. As a venture capitalist on the front line of early stage technological development, I fear that Congress is poised to do serious damage to a patent system that, albeit imperfect, does a better job of encouraging private capital investments in innovative startups than any other in the world.

Download the full text to read more about how proposed patent reforms could stifle the innovation economy of the U.S.



Comments : 0 - Last Post : Jun 18, 2010 10:17 AM by: IP Advocate
IP Advocate.org Copyright 2019

You are about to leave IPAdvocate.org and go to an outside website.

IPAdvocate.org does not control any outside website and is not responsible

for content, performance or policies, including Privacy Policy.

Thank you for visiting IPAdvocate.org.